ALL PUBLIC COMMENTS IN FULL LENGTH
RE FEDERAL RULE OF APPELLATE PROCEDURE 32.1

(CITATION OF JUDICIAL DISPOSITIONS)

Appellate Rule 32.1 is now in effect!

CLICK HERE TO READ SUMMARY OF COMMENTS, PREPARED BY PROF, PATRICK SCHILTZ, AND ALL AVAILABLE TESTIMONIES FROM APRIL 14TH PUBLIC HEARING.

Appellate Comments Chart (in pdf)

For the most recent Appellate Comments Chart (in pdf) of all comments received by the Advisory Committee  please click here.

Back to Top

COMMENTS 1 - 50

• 03-AP-001    Veronica L. Duffy
• 03-AP-002    Mark Arnold
• 03-AP-004    Daniel E. Mitchel
• 03-AP-005    David J. Weimer
• 03-AP-006    James B. Friderici
• 03-AP-007    Prof. Philip A. Pucillo
• 03-AP-008    Public Citizen Litigation
• 03-AP-009    Judge Michael Boudin
• 03-AP-010    Judge David M. Ebel
   

• 03-AP-011    Jack E. Horsley
• 03-AP-014    Paul McNeill.
• 03-AP-015    Robert N. Markle
• 03-AP-016    Philip Allen Lacovara
• 03-AP-017    J. Craig Williams
• 03-AP-018    Gayle D. Gunkut
• 03-AP-019    Judge John A. Darden
• 03-AP-020    Christopher A. Newman
   

• 03-AP-021    Prof. Brian
• 03-AP-022    Amir Weinberg
• 03-AP-023    Elia Weinbach
• 03-AP-024    Gail S. Coleman
• 03-AP-025    Eric C. Liebeler
• 03-AP-026    Judge Alfred T. Goodwin
• 03-AP-027    Deval L. Patrick
• 03-AP-028    Marc S. Mayerson
• 03-AP-029    Prof. Michele Dauber
• 03-AP-030    Benjamin I. Sachs.
   

• 03-AP-031    Robert Sargent Shriver III
• 03-AP-032    Prof. Stephen R. Barnett
• 03-AP-032    Prof. Stephen R. Barnett, addendum of February 17, 2004
• 03-AP-033    Chris Sprigman
• 03-AP-034    Steven Wyner
• 03-AP-035    Jessie Allen
• 03-AP-036    Robert H. Rotstein
• 03-AP-037    Christopher Hays
• 03-AP-038    Hon. Nazario A. "Tito" Gonzales (State Court Judge)
• 03-AP-039    James M. Rockett
• 03-AP-040    John P. Cardosi
   

• 03-AP-041    Bartko, Zankel, Tarrant(Martin Zankel)
• 03-AP-042    Kathryn E. Dobel
• 03-AP-043    Theresa Trzaskoma
• 03-AP-044    Cheryl L. Kopitzke
• 03-AP-045    Prof. Daniel P. Tokaji
• 03-AP-046    Judge Robert Boochever
• 03-AP-047    Judge Myron H. Bright
• 03-AP-048    Justice Maria P. Rivera
• 03-AP-049    Gregory S. Fisher
• 03-AP-050    Bernard J. Allard

Back to Top

COMMENTS 51 - 100

• 03-AP-051    Guy W. Stilson
• 03-AP-052    Judge John T. Noonan, Jr.
• 03-AP-053    David S. Gould, Esq
• 03-AP-054    Judge Robert W.Gettleman
• 03-AP-055    John Trasvina
• 03-AP-056    Judge Pat Williams
• 03-AP-057    Benedon & Serlin(Gerald Serlin)
• 03-AP-058    Marc Bond, Counsel, Union Oil Company of California
• 03-AP-059    Judge William A. Fletcher
• 03-AP-060    Arthur Fine, Esq & Douglas W. Bordewieck.
   

• 03-AP-061    Judge Ferdinand F.Fernandez
• 03-AP-062    Prof. Victor Fleischer
• 03-AP-063    Judge Procter Hugh
• 03-AP-064    Paul T. Cappuccio
• 03-AP-065    Judge William Schwarzer
• 03-AP-066    Judge Milton I. Shadur
• 03-AP-067    Judge Thomas G. Nelson
• 03-AP-068    Judge Ralph Adam Fine (Wisconsin Court of Appeals)
• 03-AP-069    American Bar Association
• 03-AP-070    Mark B. Jacobs
   

• 03-AP-071    Robert Bstart (commenting on FRAP 4 and not on FRAP32.1)
• 03-AP-072    Prof. Stuart Banner
• 03-AP-073    Lawrence J. Siskind
• 03-AP-074    Judge Geraldine Mund
• 03-AP-075    Judge Barry D. Silverman
• 03-AP-076    Judge James R. Browning
• 03-AP-077    Judge Joseph T. Sneed
• 03-AP-078    Prof. Jerry L. Anderson
• 03-AP-079    Brendon & Serlin
• 03-AP-080    Derek L. Shaffer
   

• 03-AP-081    Judge Richard T. Tallman
• 03-AP-082    Judge J. Clifford Wallace
• 03-AP-083    American College of Lawyers
• 03-AP-084    Kenneth N. Klee
• 03-AP-085    Sandra S. Ikuta
• 03-AP-086    U.S. Court of Appeals the Federal Circuit
• 03-AP-087    Sheryl Musgrove
• 03-AP-088    Homan Taghdiri
• 03-AP-089    Farahnaz Nourmand
• 03-AP-090     Gabriel A. Espinosa
   

• 03-AP-091    Prof. Richard W. Painter
• 03-AP-092    Robert E. Toone
• 03-AP-093    Prof. Michael S. Knoll
• 03-AP-094    Judge William A. Norris
• 03-AP-095    Robert K. Niewijk
• 03-AP-096    Brian J. Murray
• 03-AP-097    New York State Bar Association's Committee on Courts of Appellate Jurisdiction
• 03-AP-098    Robert A. Merring
• 03-AP-099    Charles M. Sevilla.
• 03-AP-100    Prof. George M. Strickler
   

Back to Top

COMMENTS 101 - 150

• 03-AP-101    Stephen A. Kroft
• 03-AP-102    Rachelle D. Barbour
• 03-AP-103    Ellis J. Horvitz
• 03-AP-104    Brian T. Fitzpatrick
• 03-AP-105    Daniel B. Levin
• 03-AP-106    Hon. Shirley M..Hufstedler
• 03-AP-107    P. Cameron DeVore
• 03-AP-108    John Vaughan
• 03-AP-109    Michael D. Young
• 03-AP-110    Hon. William C. Canby Jr.
   

• 03-AP-111    Stewart A. Baker
• 03-AP-112    Irell & Manella LLP
• 03-AP-113    Paul J. Watford
• 03-AP-114    Matthew C. Winter
• 03-AP-115    Michelle Villasenor-Grant
• 03-AP-116    Sylvia Royce
• 03-AP-117    Richard H. Rosenberg
• 03-AP-118    Roberta Gonzalez
• 03-AP-119    Mark B. Weintraub
• 03-AP-120    James R. Edwards
   

• 03-AP-121    Josh Goldfoot
• 03-AP-122    Matthew J. Sanders
• 03-AP-123    Don Willenburg
• 03-AP-124    Samuel Richard Rubin
• 03-AP-125    Richard Crane
• 03-AP-126    Hon. Richard C. Neal
• 03-AP-127    Rosetta Shatkin
• 03-AP-128    H. Joseph Nourmand
• 03-AP-129    Judge Stephen S. Trott
• 03-AP-130    Judge Carlos Tiburcio Bea
   

• 03-AP-131    Judge Dorothy W. Nelson
• 03-AP-132    Judge Kim McLane Wardlaw
• 03-AP-133     Judge Cynthia Holcomb Hall
• 03-AP-134    Judge Marsha S. Berzon
• 03-AP-135    Judge Otto R. Skopil, Jr.
• 03-AP-136    Judge Virginia A. Mathis
• 03-AP-137    Judge Jane A. Restani
• 03-AP-138    Andrew K. Nietor
• 03-AP-139     James H. Locklin
• 03-AP-140    Thomas F. Tait
   

• 03-AP-141    Theodore J. Kozloff
• 03-AP-142     Michael Barclay
• 03-AP-143    Mark Kerslake
• 03-AP-144    Joseph W. Cotchett et al
• 03-AP-145    Jeffrey B. Coyne
• 03-AP-146    Jonathan A. Loeb
• 03-AP-147    Marwit Capital (Chris L. Britt,President)
• 03-AP-148    Sandberg Furniture
• 03-AP-149    Craig Rosler
• 03-AP-150    Lisa Perrochet(Addendum has 3 Attachments)
   

Back to Top

COMMENTS 151 - 200

• 03-AP-151    Jerome B. Falk, Jr.
• 03-AP-152   Nicole C. Hancock
• 03-AP-153    Prof. Mark Lemley
• 03-AP-154    Martha M. Hall
• 03-AP-155    Judge Robert K. Puglia (State of California Appellate Judge, Retired)
• 03-AP-156    Judge Jerome Farris
• 03-AP-157    Gregory T.H. Lee
• 03-AP-158    Prof. Eugene Volokh
• 03-AP-159    Allison Claire
• 03-AP-160    Lara A. Bazelon
   

• 03-AP-161    Leslie A. Hakala
• 03-AP-162    Davina T. Chen
• 03-AP-163    Carole Tkacz
• 03-AP-164    William A. Burck
• 03-AP-165    Monica Knox
• 03-AP-166    Marcy J. Tiffany
• 03-AP-167    Judge Warren J. Ferguson
• 03-AP-168     Mary E. Kelly
• 03-AP-169    Judge Alex Kozinski
• 03-AP-170    Judge Thomas M. Reavley
   

• 03-AP-171    Karyn H. Bucur
• 03-AP-172    Carlton F. Gunn
• 03-AP-173    Kurt D. Hermansen
• 03-AP-174    Judge Vincent P. Zurzolo, Central District CA Bankruptcy Judge
• 03-AP-175    Knut S. Johnson
• 03-AP-176    Donald S. Frick
• 03-AP-177    Kara B. Persson
• 03-AP-178    Gregory Nicolaysen
• 03-AP-179    Evan A. Jenness
• 03-AP-180    W. John Thiel

• 03-AP-181    Diane M. Regan
   
• 03-AP-182    Kurt D. Hermansen, (no link: repeat of 173)
• 03-AP-183    Gretchen Fusilier
• 03-AP-184    Chase A. Scolnick
• 03-AP-185    Donna Bader
• 03-AP-186    Harvey I. Saferstein
• 03-AP-187    Justin Farar
• 03-AP-188    W. Dea Montague
• 03-AP-189    Bethany L. O'Neill
• 03-AP-190    Timothy A. Scott
   

• 03-AP-191    Jerald L. Brainin
• 03-AP-192    Judge Michael Boudin
• 03-AP-193    W.F. Rylaarsdam, Associate Justice, CA Court of Appeal
• 03-AP-194    Craig Wilkie
• 03-AP-195    Myra Sun
• 03-AP-196    Richard D. Marks
• 03-AP-197    Mark S. Pulliam
• 03-AP-198    Prof. Ethan Stone
• 03-AP-199    Michael Tanaka
• 03-AP-200    Michael A. Brodsky.
   

Back to Top

COMMENTS 201 - 250

• 03-AP-201    Los Angeles County Bar Association Appellate Courts Committee
• 03-AP-202    Hayward J. Kaiser
• 03-AP-203    Patricia Lofton
• 03-AP-204    David M. Luboff
• 03-AP-205    Hartwell V. Harris, law student
• 03-AP-206    Dr. Philip K. Anthony
• 03-AP-207    Michael E. Lopez
• 03-AP-208    Jonathan M. Shaw
• 03-AP-209    Kerry Hubers
• 03-AP-210    Steven R. Minor
   

• 03-AP-211    J.Christopher Desmond
• 03-AP-212    Hugh R. Law
• 03-AP-213    Robert Don Gifford
• 03-AP-214    Charles E. Young, Jr.
• 03-AP-215    Michael Bergfeld
• 03-AP-216    Stephen Marsh
• 03-AP-217    Samuel M. Ventola
• 03-AP-218    Stephen C. Neal
• 03-AP-219    Prof. Andrew M. Siegel
• 03-AP-220    David C. Pauling
   

• 03-AP-221    Ward Farnsworth
• 03-AP-222    James B. Morse, Jr.
• 03-AP-223    David R. Fine
• 03-AP-224    Victor H. Woodworth
• 03-AP-225    Ashley Doherty
• 03-AP-226    John M. Nettleton,
• 03-AP-227    David W. Floren
• 03-AP-228    Charles M. Miller
• 03-AP-229    Arlus J. Stephens, Esq
• 03-AP-230    Roy M. Jessee
   

• 03-AP-231    Damon A. Katz
• 03-AP-232    John A. Taylor, Jr.
• 03-AP-233    Judge Pamela Ann Rymer
• 03-AP-234    Stephen Yagman
• 03-AP-235    ACLU Foundation of Southern California
• 03-AP-236    Jana L. Torok
• 03-AP-237    Mary French
• 03-AP-238    Nom D. Plume
• 03-AP-239    Kenneth J. Schmier
• 03-AP-240    Bruce Livingston
   

• 03-AP-241    Katherine Kimball Windsor
• 03-AP-242    John J. Cleary
• 03-AP-243    William T. Rintala
• 03-AP-244    Fred H. Altshuler
• 03-AP-245    Sean W. Gallagher
• 03-AP-246    Judy Clarke
• 03-AP-247     Karen L. Landau
• 03-AP-248    Oswald Parada
• 03-AP-249    Christopher R.J. Pace
• 03-AP-250    Judge David Alan Ezra
   

Back to Top

COMMENTS 251 - 300

• 03-AP-251    Hoyt Y. Sze
• 03-AP-252    Judge John E. Ryan
• 03-AP-253    Vince G. Chhabria
• 03-AP-254    Danny Chou
• 03-AP-255    Raoul D. Kennedy
• 03-AP-256    Michael Garcia
• 03-AP-257    Susan Lew
• 03-AP-258    Mark Ouweleen
• 03-AP-259    J. Al Latham, Jr.
• 03-AP-260    James Stern
   

• 03-AP-261    John P. Frantz
• 03-AP-262    Eric H. Joss
• 03-AP-263    Paul Grossman
• 03-AP-264    Douglas Feick
• 03-AP-265    Jacob Aftergood
• 03-AP-266    Fred H. Bartlit, Jr.
• 03-AP-267    Stephen P. Berzon
• 03-AP-268    California La Raza Lawyers Assoc.
• 03-AP-269    Judge Boyce F. Martin, Jr.
• 03-AP-270    Andrew Rubin
   

• 03-AP-271    Daniel E. Monnat
• 03-AP-272    Verizon
• 03-AP-273    Judge Richard A. Paez
• 03-AP-274    Prof. Gregory N. Mandel
• 03-AP-275    James K. Jenkins
• 03-AP-276    Ingrid Leverett
• 03-AP-277    Townsend and Townsend
• 03-AP-278    Judge Ellen Carroll
• 03-AP-279    SherrinJ. Charlick
• 03-AP-280    Judge William W. Bedsworth

• 03-AP-281     Judge John J. Hargrove
• 03-AP-282     Julian Moore
• 03-AP-283     Prof. Michael Sinclair
• 03-AP-284     Paul Freda
• 03-AP-285     Judge Diarmuid F. O'Scannlain
• 03-AP-286     Steven A. Aftergood (FAS)
• 03-AP-287     Mario G. Conte
• 03-AP-288    Judge A. Wallace Tashima
• 03-AP-289    Judge Edward Leavy
• 03-AP-290    Judge Arthur L. Alarcon

• 03-AP-291    Judge Michael Daly Hawkins
• 03-AP-292    Judge Robert R. Beezer
• 03-AP-293    Judge Ruggero J. Aldisert
• 03-AP-294    Judge Maureen A. Tighe
• 03-AP-295    Justice Paul Boland (California Court of Appeal)
• 03-AP-296    Justice Gary E.Strankman (Special Master, California)
• 03-AP-297    Judge S. Jay Plager
• 03-AP-298    Prof. Charles E. Cohen
• 03-AP-299    Kevin A. Cranman
• 03-AP-300    Wayne Willis

Back to Top

COMMENTS 301 - 350

• 03-AP-301    Eugene M. Paige
• 03-AP-302    Christian A. Weideman
• 03-AP-303    Franny A. Forsman
• 03-AP-304    Marilyn Weiss Alper
• 03-AP-305    Manuel U. Araujo
• 03-AP-306    Jonathan C. Wilson
• 03-AP-307    Daniel M. Nelson
• 03-AP-308    C. Brooks Cutter
• 03-AP-309    Joseph R. Dreitler
• 03-AP-310    Anthony J. Vlatas

• 03-AP-311    Guy Mizrahi
• 03-AP-312    Quin Denvir
• 03-AP-313    David B.H. Williams
• 03-AP-314    Assoc. Dean & Prof. Scott A. Altman
• 03-AP-315    Michael Bishop
• 03-AP-316    Members of Appellate Dept. of Sedgwick, Detert, Moran and Arnold LLP
• 03-AP-317    Larry Neuton (Addendum)
• 03-AP-318    Judge Consuelo M.Callahan
• 03-AP-319    State Bar of California, Committee on Appellate Courts (2 separate letters)
• 03-AP-320    Cynthia S. Hahn

• 03-AP-321    Lawrence A. Callaghan
• 03-AP-322    E. Vaughn Dunnigan
• 03-AP-323    Debra D. Coplan
• 03-AP-324    Dr. Mark S. Bellamy (J.D., Ph.D.)
• 03-AP-325    Melinda Eades
• 03-AP-326    Robert LeMoine
• 03-AP-327    Judge Jay S. Bybee
• 03-AP-328    Holly R. Paul
• 03-AP-329    Judge John M. Walker,Jr. et al (2nd Circuit Court of Appeals)
• 03-AP-330    Robert K. Hur

• 03-AP-331    Robert A. Holland
• 03-AP-332    Harvey Winer
• 03-AP-333    Alexander Bunin
• 03-AP-334    Professor Rory K. Little
• 03-AP-335    Judge Kenneth F. Ripple
• 03-AP-336    Kelly M. Klaus
• 03-AP-337    David M. Stern
• 03-AP-338    Jennifer Schlotterbeck
• 03-AP-339    Lauren A. Degnan, et al.
• 03-AP-340    Jason F. Carr

• 03-AP-341    White O’Connor Curry Avanzado, LLP
• 03-AP-342    Randall S. Lockhart
• 03-AP-343    Kelli L. Sager
• 03-AP-344    Lisa Hay
• 03-AP-345    Christian E. Mammen et al.
• 03-AP-346    Sheldon W. Presser
• 03-AP-347    Los Angeles County Bar Association Litigation
• 03-AP-348    Troy Foster
• 03-AP-349    Marc S. Cohen & Ashleigh A. Danker
• 03-AP-350    Judge M. Margaret McKeown

Back to Top

COMMENTS 351 - 400

• 03-AP-351    Judge Alan M. Ahart
• 03-AP-352    Gretchen M. Nelson
• 03-AP-353    Stephen R. English
• 03-AP-354    Michael K. Powell
• 03-AP-355    David M. Porter
• 03-AP-356    Shepppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton, LLP
• 03-AP-357    Michael J. Kennedy
• 03-AP-358    Daniel J. Albregts, Ltd
• 03-AP-359    Judge Mark V. Holmes
• 03-AP-360    Carlton F.W. Larson

• 03-AP-361    Jennifer M. Mason
• 03-AP-362    David A. Schwartz
• 03-AP-363    Barry A. Cohen
• 03-AP-364    Kent L. Richland
• 03-AP-365    Bruce M. Ramer
• 03-AP-366    Judge Raymond C. Fisher
• 03-AP-367    Judge Frank H. Easterbrook
• 03-AP-368    Judge Douglas H. Ginsburg
• 03-AP-369    Prof. Arthur D. Hellman
• 03-AP-370    Thomas M. Barba (FRAP 35)

• 03-AP-371    Steven T. Wax
• 03-AP-372    Hon. Arthur G. Scotland (Presiding Justice, Cal. Court of Appeal)
• 03-AP-373    Monica J. Wahl
• 03-AP-374    Federal Bar Association Northern District of California Chapter
• 03-AP-375    Office of the Federal Public Defender, E.D. of North Carolina
• 03-AP-376    K. John Shaffer
• 03-AP-377    Peter C. Wolff, Jr.
• 03-AP-378    Alexander Silvert
• 03-AP-379    Kreindler & Kreindler, LLP
• 03-AP-380    Prof. Thomas Healy

• 03-AP-381    Michael L. Goldman
• 03-AP-382    State of Washington Attorney General’s Office
• 03-AP-383    Ellen Callahan
• 03-AP-384    Thomas W. Hillier, II, Federal Public Defender
• 03-AP-385    James S. Gifford
• 03-AP-386    Roger James Peven
• 03-AP-387    Andrew J. Guilford
• 03-AP-388    Stephen R. Hormel
• 03-AP-389    Sondra K. Barbour
• 03-AP-390    Michael Pescetta

• 03-AP-391    Jeffrey B. Demain
• 03-AP-392    Prof. Ross E. Davies
• 03-AP-393    State Bar of California(Also Committee on Federal Courts, 2 letters)
• 03-AP-394    State Bar of Michigan
• 03-AP-395    Bill Lockyer, Attorney General
• 03-AP-396    Majority of judges of U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
• 03-AP-397    Judge Timothy B. Dyk
• 03-AP-398    Judge Sidney R. Thomas
• 03-AP-399    Judge Jeffrey W. Johnson
• 03-AP-400    Judge Susan P. Graber

Back to Top

COMMENTS 401 - 450

• 03-AP-401    Judge M. Blaine Michael
• 03-AP-402    Judge Stephen Reinhardt
• 03-AP-403    Judge David R. Thompson
• 03-AP-404    Justice Laurence D. Kay (California Court of Appeal)
• 03-AP-405    Judge Barry Russell
• 03-AP-406    Trial Lawyers for Public Justice
• 03-AP-407    John F. McGuire
• 03-AP-408    Beverly B. Mann (with Addendum)
• 03-AP-409    Federal Circuit Bar Association
• 03-AP-410    Advisory Council of the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit

• 03-AP-411    Igor V. Timofeyev
• 03-AP-412    Harry Susman
• 03-AP-413    Maria E. Stratton
• 03-AP-414    Citizens for Voluntary Trade
• 03-AP-415    Hispanic National Bar Association
• 03-AP-416    Scott Bales
• 03-AP-417    Farmers Group, Inc.
• 03-AP-418    Nicholas Drees,Esq.
• 03-AP-419    S.Ann Salisbury
• 03-AP-420    Albert S. Golbert

• 03-AP-421    Craig L. Hymowitz
• 03-AP-422    Kathryn R. Haun
• 03-AP-423    Michael D. Thomas
• 03-AP-424    David R. Parry
• 03-AP-425    Ethan Lipsig
• 03-AP-426    Kurt L. Grossman
• 03-AP-427    Joanne Mariner
• 03-AP-428    Leonard F. Joy and Barry D. Leiwant
• 03-AP-429    Federal Bar Association Orange County Chapter
• 03-AP-430    Bruce Wieder

• 03-AP-431    Hon. Ramsey Clark
• 03-AP-432    Bennett Evan Cooper
• 03-AP-433    Jeffrey A. Lamken
• 03-AP-434    Ira Brad Matetsky
• 03-AP-435    Prof. Richard B. Cappalli
• 03-AP-436    Barry J. Portman
• 03-AP-437    Patricia Plunkett
• 03-AP-438    Staff & Panel Attorneys, Federal Defender Program, Northern District of Illinois
• 03-AP-439    Office of Federal Public Defender, Eastern District of Virginia
• 03-AP-440    Adam J. Pliska

• 03-AP-441    Former Law Clerks of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
• 03-AP-442    Anne Walstrom
• 03-AP-443    Ben Hernandez
• 03-AP-444    Elwood Lui & Alan E. Friedman
• 03-AP-445    Nicholas V. Vieth
• 03-AP-446    Rebecca L. Pennell
• 03-AP-447    Louis Kwall
• 03-AP-448    Bradley A. Conway,Esq.
• 03-AP-449    Dr. Elizabeth A. Pawlak, (J.D., Ph.D., D.Sc.)
• 03-AP-450    William C. Carrico

Back to Top

COMMENTS 451 - END

• 03-AP-451    Armando Garcia
• 03-AP-452    Alan R. Soven
• 03-AP-453    Anne R. Traum
• 03-AP-454    Michael N. Loebl
• 03-AP-455    L. Rachel Helyar
• 03-AP-456    Citizens for Voluntary Trade
• 03-AP-457    Honey Kessler Amado
• 03-AP-458    Steven A. Engel
• 03-AP-459    Rich Curtner
• 03-AP-460    Susan Kearns

• 03-AP-461    Katina Whalen
• 03-AP-462    Robert G. Badal et al
• 03-AP-463    Barry W. Beroset
• 03-AP-464    The Association of the Bar of the City of New York
• 03-AP-465    Gary Michael Coutin
• 03-AP-466    Rowan D. Wilson
• 03-AP-467    Prof. Brett H. McDonnell
• 03-AP-468    Robin Meadow
• 03-AP-469    Kenneth W. Starr
• 03-AP-470    Peter Kontio & Todd David

• 03-AP-471    Chief Justice Ronald M. George (Supreme Court of California)
• 03-AP-472    Mark Snyderman
• 03-AP-473    Leslie R. Weatherhead
• 03-AP-474    Steven F. Hubachek
• 03-AP-475    Stephen N. Bernstein
• 03-AP-476    Walter L. Grantham, Jr.
• 03-AP-477    Prof. Nhan Vu
• 03-AP-478    Lee A. Casey
• 03-AP-479    David B. Rivkin, Jr.
• 03-AP-480    Christopher P. Saxer

• 03-AP-481    Lynn C. Merring, Librarian
• 03-AP-482    Anne M. Voigts
• 03-AP-483    Barbara A. Winters
• 03-AP-484    Judge Joseph Reichmann
• 03-AP-485   Jeffrey A. Aaron
• 03-AP-485   Antonio D. Martini

Back to Top

COMMENTS POSTMARKED AFTER DEADLINE

• 03-AP-487    Public Citizen Litigation Group (Paul Alan Levy)
• 03-AP-488    Victor Sherman
• 03-AP-489    Janet Sherman,
• 03-AP-490    Daniel L. Geyser
• 03-AP-491    Social Security Administration (Lisa de Soto, General counsel)
• 03-AP-492    Diane Knox
• 03-AP-493    Wendeline De Zan
• 03-AP-494    Kirk N. Kirkconnell
• 03-AP-495    Wilbur C. Smith III
• 03-AP-496    Judge Stanley F. Birch, Jr.
• 03-AP-497    Robert S. Griscti, Esq.
• 03-AP-498    Pedro Sandoval, Jr., Esq.
• 03-AP-499    Eighth Circuit Judges (Judge James B. Loken)
• 03-AP-500    Joel Hirschhorn

• 03-AP-501    Kevin R. Boyle
• 03-AP-502    Mary Eugenia Gates
• 03-AP-503    Michael T. Burns
• 03-AP-504    Gregory S. Emerson
• 03-AP-505    Judge Paul R. Michel
• 03-AP-506    Judge Daniel M. Friedman
• 03-AP-507    Prof. Fred S. McChesney
• 03-AP-508    Robert L. Jovick
• 03-AP-509    Mark F. Adams
• 03-AP-510    Shaun S. McCrea
• 03-AP-511    John Henry Hingson III,
• 03-AP-512    John P. Cardillo
• 03-AP-513    James L. Martin

Back to Top